Question
If a customer asks ChatGPT the same question twice, do they get the same company?
Often not. When we asked the same assistant the same question again in a fresh chat, the first company named matched only about half the time (53%).
Updated 19 November 2026
In our checks, we asked each assistant each wording three or four times in fresh chats. We compared every pair of repeats: 477 of 906 pairs put the same shop first (53%). In 82 of 232 repeat sets, every answer put the same shop first. Perplexity was the steadiest (74%), then ChatGPT (46%), then Gemini (35%).
By assistant
A pair is two answers from the same assistant to the same question about the same town.
| Assistant | HVAC: same first pick | Plumbing: same first pick | Every repeat the same |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 46% (115 of 252) | 48% (40 of 84) | 20 of 80 |
| Perplexity | 72% (178 of 246) | 79% (57 of 72) | 47 of 75 |
| Gemini | 38% (70 of 182) | 24% (17 of 70) | 15 of 77 |
| All three | 53% (363 of 680) | 50% (114 of 226) | 82 of 232 |
What this means for your shop
- Running one test in ChatGPT proves very little. Coming up first once can be a fluke. So can being left out once.
- You have to count across many tries. That's why our check asks fifty times and gives you a share, not a single rank.
- If you only come up first part of the time, small fixes to your website and listings can help tip the scale.
How we counted: 800 answers from ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini to homeowner questions for HVAC and plumbing in 16 town checks across Central Texas, 14 to 17 November 2026. All asked in fresh chats with no account history. A company counts as named when the answer lists it. The first one listed is the first pick. We left company names out on purpose.
Common questions
If a business comes up first in ChatGPT once, is it set?
Maybe not. In our data, repeats of the exact same question put the same company first only 53% of the time. Ask it again in a fresh chat, and check the other assistants too.