Question
Do ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini recommend the same contractor?
Mostly no. In 12 Central Texas towns checked for HVAC, all three picked the same top shop in 1. In 4 towns checked for plumbers, they agreed in 0.
Updated 19 November 2026
We asked each assistant the same homeowner questions, town by town, and counted which shop it put first most often. For HVAC, all three agreed in 1 of 12 towns, two agreed in 7, and each had its own pick in 4. For plumbers, all three agreed in 0 of 4 towns and two agreed in 0.
Town by town
Company labels are per town (Company A = most first picks in that town). "Tied" means the assistant had two or more shops even on first picks.
| Town | Each assistant's favourite (labels are per town) | Same favourite? | Companies all three named |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bastrop (HVAC) | ChatGPT Company B, Perplexity Company A, Gemini Company E | no | 2 of 18 |
| Buda (HVAC) | ChatGPT Company A, Perplexity Company A, Gemini Company A | all three | 2 of 25 |
| Cedar Park (HVAC) | ChatGPT Company A, Perplexity Company B, Gemini Company A (tied) | two of three | 3 of 27 |
| Dripping Springs (HVAC) | ChatGPT Company C, Perplexity Company A, Gemini Company A | two of three | 5 of 23 |
| Georgetown (HVAC) | ChatGPT Company A, Perplexity Company A, Gemini Company B | two of three | 1 of 23 |
| Hutto (HVAC) | ChatGPT Company D (tied), Perplexity Company C, Gemini Company A | two of three | 2 of 21 |
| Kyle (HVAC) | ChatGPT Company A, Perplexity Company C, Gemini Company B | no | 2 of 34 |
| Leander (HVAC) | ChatGPT Company A, Perplexity Company C (tied), Gemini Company B (tied) | no | 3 of 23 |
| Pflugerville (HVAC) | ChatGPT Company D (tied), Perplexity Company F (tied), Gemini Company A | two of three | 2 of 24 |
| Round Rock (HVAC) | ChatGPT Company B, Perplexity Company A, Gemini Company A | two of three | 2 of 22 |
| San Marcos (HVAC) | ChatGPT Company B (tied), Perplexity Company A, Gemini Company A | two of three | 4 of 24 |
| Taylor (HVAC) | ChatGPT Company A, Perplexity Company B, Gemini Company D | no | 2 of 26 |
| Georgetown (Plumbing) | ChatGPT Company B, Perplexity Company D, Gemini Company C | no | 2 of 33 |
| Hutto (Plumbing) | ChatGPT Company B, Perplexity Company A, Gemini Company C | no | 0 of 25 |
| Round Rock (Plumbing) | ChatGPT Company A, Perplexity Company B, Gemini Company E (tied) | no | 3 of 36 |
| Taylor (Plumbing) | ChatGPT Company B, Perplexity Company A, Gemini Company C | no | 2 of 14 |
Why they differ
Each assistant pulls from different places. ChatGPT and Perplexity show links, and their links differ (see which sites they cite for HVAC). Few shops make every list. Across the HVAC towns, 30 of the 290 shops named showed up in all three. For plumbers, it was 7 of 108.
What this means for your shop
- Checking one assistant tells you very little about the other two. Check all three.
- Making every assistant's list is rare. It's a real advantage when you do.
- A homeowner who checks two apps can get two different first picks for the same job.
How we counted: 800 answers from ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini to homeowner questions for HVAC and plumbing in 16 town checks across Central Texas, 14 to 17 November 2026. All asked in fresh chats with no account history. A company counts as named when the answer lists it. The first one listed is the first pick. We left company names out on purpose.
Common questions
Which AI assistant matters most for a local contractor?
We don't know which app your customers use. We do know the apps disagree: in 4 of 12 HVAC towns, each had a different top pick. That's why our check asks all three.