Question
Does the way a customer words the question change which company AI recommends?
Yes. In every one of the 16 town checks, the top shop changed between at least two of the five ways a homeowner might ask.
Updated 19 November 2026
For each town, we asked the same thing five ways: an urgent repair, "the best", "local and owner-operated", a short typed search, and a zip code search. In 16 of 16 town checks, at least two of those wordings had a different top shop.
The five wordings
For HVAC, with the town and zip code filled in:
- AC stopped cooling, repair tomorrow
- the best HVAC company, honest and fairly priced
- a local, owner-operated company, not a chain
- a short typed search (ac repair, furnace not heating)
- a heater that won't turn on, near the zip code
For plumbers: a leaking water heater needing a Thursday visit, the best fairly priced plumber for a clogged drain, a local owner-operated plumber, a short typed search, and a water heater leak near the zip code.
Town by town
Each cell shows the shop with the most first picks for that wording, and how many of those answers it took. Labels are per town (Company A = most first picks in that town overall).
| Town | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bastrop (HVAC) | Company A (tied), 4 of 12 | Company D (tied), 3 of 11 | Company B, 6 of 9 | Company A, 3 of 9 | Company A, 3 of 9 |
| Buda (HVAC) | Company D, 3 of 12 | Company B, 6 of 11 | Company A, 4 of 9 | Company A, 4 of 9 | Company A, 9 of 9 |
| Cedar Park (HVAC) | Company A, 5 of 12 | Company A (tied), 3 of 11 | Company D, 4 of 9 | Company A, 4 of 9 | Company J (tied), 2 of 9 |
| Dripping Springs (HVAC) | Company D, 5 of 12 | Company B, 9 of 11 | Company F, 3 of 9 | Company A, 5 of 9 | Company A, 5 of 9 |
| Georgetown (HVAC) | Company A, 6 of 12 | Company A, 8 of 11 | Company A, 3 of 9 | Company A, 7 of 9 | Company B (tied), 2 of 9 |
| Hutto (HVAC) | Company A, 5 of 12 | Company C, 4 of 11 | Company E, 3 of 9 | Company A, 4 of 9 | Company A, 5 of 9 |
| Kyle (HVAC) | Company B, 4 of 12 | Company A, 7 of 11 | Company A, 3 of 9 | Company B, 5 of 9 | Company A (tied), 3 of 9 |
| Leander (HVAC) | Company C, 3 of 12 | Company G, 3 of 11 | Company B, 4 of 9 | Company A, 3 of 9 | Company J (tied), 3 of 9 |
| Pflugerville (HVAC) | Company D (tied), 3 of 12 | Company E, 4 of 11 | Company B, 4 of 9 | Company H, 3 of 9 | Company C, 6 of 9 |
| Round Rock (HVAC) | Company A, 4 of 12 | Company E, 3 of 11 | Company A (tied), 4 of 9 | Company A, 4 of 9 | Company H, 3 of 9 |
| San Marcos (HVAC) | Company C, 5 of 12 | Company A, 5 of 11 | Company E (tied), 3 of 9 | Company A (tied), 3 of 9 | Company A, 5 of 9 |
| Taylor (HVAC) | Company C (tied), 3 of 12 | Company A, 5 of 11 | Company B, 3 of 9 | Company B, 3 of 9 | Company G (tied), 2 of 9 |
| Georgetown (Plumbing) | Company A, 5 of 12 | Company C (tied), 3 of 11 | Company F, 3 of 9 | Company D (tied), 3 of 9 | Company E, 3 of 9 |
| Hutto (Plumbing) | Company E, 3 of 12 | Company A, 5 of 11 | Company H (tied), 2 of 9 | Company A, 3 of 9 | Company C, 2 of 9 |
| Round Rock (Plumbing) | Company D (tied), 3 of 12 | Company A (tied), 4 of 11 | Company G (tied), 3 of 9 | Company A, 3 of 9 | Company K, 3 of 9 |
| Taylor (Plumbing) | Company A, 5 of 12 | Company A, 6 of 11 | Company C, 7 of 9 | Company D (tied), 3 of 9 | Company B, 3 of 9 |
Asking for a local, owner-operated company
When the question asked for a local, owner-operated shop, a national franchise came first in 1 of 106 HVAC answers and 1 of 34 plumbing answers. Across the other four wordings, franchises took 36 of 472 for HVAC and 12 of 154 for plumbing.
What this means for your shop
- Think in terms of jobs, not keywords. "AC stopped cooling, can someone come tomorrow" is a different question from "best HVAC company", and it gets a different answer.
- A page that matches the exact job—the town, the repair, your hours—gives the assistant plain facts to read. See what assistants look for.
- If you are owner-operated, put those exact words on your site. Homeowners ask for it, and the assistants repeat it.
How we counted: 800 answers from ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini to homeowner questions for HVAC and plumbing in 16 town checks across Central Texas, 14 to 17 November 2026. All asked in fresh chats with no account history. A company counts as named when the answer lists it. The first one listed is the first pick. We left company names out on purpose.
Common questions
Which wording should a contractor's website target?
The ones your customers actually use. In our data, the top pick changed with the wording in 16 of 16 towns. A website that covers urgent repairs, owner-operated service, and your zip codes gives you more chances to show up.