Question

Do national franchises win AI recommendations over local shops?

No. Companies without a national franchise brand took most first picks. A national franchise came first in 37 of 578 HVAC answers and 13 of 188 plumbing answers that named a company.

Updated 19 November 2026

We counted a first pick as a franchise if it used a national brand name (like One Hour, Aire Serv, TemperaturePro, Roto-Rooter, Mr. Rooter, or Benjamin Franklin). For HVAC, franchises took the first pick in 37 of 578 answers that named a shop (6%). For plumbing, they took 13 of 188 (7%). Franchises showed up somewhere in the answer in 106 of 600 HVAC asks and 40 of 200 plumbing asks. They make the list more often than they top it.

First picks that went to a franchise brand

Out of the answers that named at least one company.

AssistantHVACPlumbing
ChatGPT7 of 2040 of 68
Perplexity15 of 2007 of 57
Gemini15 of 1746 of 63

But their websites get linked a lot

Franchise websites showed up in the links of 136 of 408 ChatGPT and Perplexity HVAC answers, and 52 of 136 plumbing answers—mostly in Perplexity's source lists. Their national pages are all over the web, even when their local shop isn't the top pick.

What this means for your shop

How we counted: 800 answers from ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini to homeowner questions for HVAC and plumbing in 16 town checks across Central Texas, 14 to 17 November 2026. All asked in fresh chats with no account history. A company counts as named when the answer lists it. The first one listed is the first pick. We left company names out on purpose.

Common questions

Can a small HVAC or plumbing shop beat a franchise in ChatGPT?

In our data, yes, most of the time. National franchise brands took 6% of HVAC first picks and 7% of plumbing first picks across Central Texas. Companies without a franchise name took the rest.