AEO and GEO

How do you measure AI visibility across ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini?

Measuring AI visibility takes repeated checks on the same realistic customer questions, because an assistant often names a different business first when asked again. In our own checks across 16 Central Texas towns (800 total answers, 906 repeat pairs), asking the exact same question again put the same business first only 53% of the time. That is why 56 publishers recommend a fixed prompt panel and 29 recommend running each prompt multiple times.

Updated 19 November 2026

To measure AI visibility, ask a fixed set of customer questions again and again, and pair those answer checks with your own referral data and customer intake. In our corpus of 320 publishers, 56 back a fixed panel of prompts, 47 back finding which sites the assistants cite, 35 back analytics set up to see AI referrals, and 29 back running each prompt many times. A single spot check in your own browser tells you little, because the same question can return a different first pick the next time. Asking new customers how they found you (23 publishers back it) catches what analytics misses.

What sources say to measure

Each row below is one tactic, and each cell counts how many of the 320 publishers in our 435 saved sources took that stance. A publisher can take more than one stance, so the columns do not add up to a total.

StepRecommend itMeasured it workingCall it useless or warnMeasured no effectMeasured harmOur label
A fixed panel of prompts run on a schedule; share of answers naming the business5441100Recommended and measured
Run each prompt many times, since answers vary256510Recommended and measured
Find which sources the assistants cite for the target prompts, then get onto those4110400Recommended and measured
Find the real prompts customers use183100Recommended and measured
Analytics set up to see AI referrals3511000Contested
Ask every new customer how they found the business194201Recommended and measured
Track how AI visitors convert against other visitors268510Recommended and measured

How much answers vary when you ask again

Between 14 November 2026 and 17 November 2026, we ran 16 town checks in Central Texas for HVAC and plumbing (800 answers, comparing 906 repeat pairs of the exact same question on the same assistant). Across all three assistants, the same business came back in first place only 53% of the time: 74% on Perplexity, 46% on ChatGPT, and 35% on Gemini. All three assistants agreed on the same top business in just 1 of the 16 towns.

AssistantSame first pick when asked again
ChatGPT46%
Perplexity74%
Gemini35%
All three53%

How tracking tools collect their answers

If you are choosing a tracking tool, ask how it gets its answers: from the logged-out app people actually use, or from a developer API that may search differently. Below are two trackers' own method notes, quoted from their sites; the stability figure in the first is the vendor's own number.

Chatgpt.com in a browser, logged out and set to your region.
The official Sonar API, with its sources.
Same mention result next day. Based on 1,034 comparisons, July 2026.

MentionFlow, Methodology, read 19 November 2026

Peec AI’s UI scraping simulates real user interactions, so the data it collects matches what the average user sees on these AI platforms.

Peec AI, Peec AI docs: how Peec AI collects data, read 19 November 2026

What this means for your business

We saved 435 guides, studies, forum threads and platform docs from 320 publishers in full, recorded 1592 word-for-word method statements across 99 tactics, and logged 216 reported results with numbers. Every count is by publisher, not by article, so one prolific blog only gets one vote per stance, and every quote is checked word for word against our saved copy. A high count is not proof that a tactic works: many GEO writers sell GEO services or software, and a measured claim usually means one site's before-and-after numbers rather than a controlled test.

Common questions

Why do ChatGPT and Gemini give different answers to the same question?

The assistants generate each answer fresh, and the web searches behind them can return different pages from one run to the next. In our 906 repeat pairs across 16 town checks, the first-named business stayed the same only 53% of the time overall (46% on ChatGPT, 74% on Perplexity, 35% on Gemini).